Your Guide to the Definition of Done

Do not index

Let’s be honest. How many times has your team popped the champagne for a feature release, only to get slammed with a tidal wave of "minor" bugs and confused user complaints a week later? You thought you were done, but the work just keeps boomeranging back.

That’s not the sign of a bad team. It’s the classic symptom of a weak—or completely missing—Definition of Done (DoD).

Why Your "Done" Work Probably Isn't Done

When a developer says a task is "done," they might mean "the code is written." But when a product manager hears "done," they’re thinking "it's live, bug-free, and customers are loving it."

That gap? That’s where projects go completely off the rails. It’s a silent killer of productivity, a drain on morale, and the primary source of endless, frustrating rework. You know, the kind that makes your best engineer question their career choices.

From "Code Complete" to "Truly Shipped"

A proper Definition of Done is the antidote to this ambiguity. It's a clear, concise, and collectively owned checklist that defines what it means for any piece of work to be truly complete. Think of it as your team's formal pact with quality.

It’s not just about functionality; it's a quality gate that ensures every user story or task is coded, tested, reviewed, merged, documented, and ready for release without someone needing to circle back.

A strong DoD isn't a suggestion—it’s a non-negotiable standard that protects your team from the most common pitfalls:

Endless Rework: It stops half-baked features from moving down the pipeline, only to be sent back riddled with bugs.

User Frustration: It guarantees that what you ship is stable, reliable, and meets a consistent quality bar every single time.

Mounting Tech Debt: It forces you to deal with documentation and testing now, preventing a tangled mess of undocumented code later.

Ultimately, a DoD transforms your entire software development lifecycle. It shifts the focus from just doing the work to actually delivering real, sustainable value. We're moving beyond the vague promise of "it's done" to a world of provable completeness.

Definition of Done vs. Acceptance Criteria

This is where things get fuzzy, even for sharp teams.

They’ll spend hours writing meticulous Acceptance Criteria (AC) for a user story and figure, "Great, that's our Definition of Done." It’s an easy mistake to make, but it’s like confusing the recipe for a single dish with the health code standards for the entire kitchen.

One tells you how to make the soup. The other ensures the whole restaurant doesn’t give someone food poisoning.

Acceptance Criteria are laser-focused on a single user story or feature. They spell out the expected behavior from a user's point of view—a contract for one specific piece of work.

The Scope Showdown

The Definition of Done, on the other hand, is the universal quality bar that all work has to clear. It’s the team's shared promise of quality and completeness for every single thing they ship, no matter what the feature is.

Let's play this out with a startup building a new onboarding flow.

Acceptance Criteria might look like this: "A new user can sign up with their Google account," or "The user is prompted to invite three teammates after registration." These are specific, testable conditions just for that feature.

The Definition of Done would include things like: "All new code is peer-reviewed," "Unit test coverage is above 85%," "Accessibility standards are met," and "User-facing docs are updated."

See the gap? A developer could build a feature that perfectly meets every single one of its Acceptance Criteria. The Google sign-up works like a charm. But if the code was never reviewed and no documentation was written, it fails the Definition of Done. It's not really finished.

This is exactly how tech debt piles up and integration nightmares are born. The feature works, but it’s a ticking time bomb of poor quality that will inevitably go off—probably in the form of angry customer support tickets. To get this right, you first have to nail your stories, and our guide on how to write good user stories is the perfect place to start.

A feature can meet all its AC but still fail to be truly 'done.' Understanding this distinction is the first step to stopping incomplete work from ever reaching production.

Expanding the Framework with 'Ready'

The conversation doesn't just stop at "Done" versus "Accepted." High-performing agile teams often bring in a third concept: the Definition of Ready (DoR).

If the DoD is the gatekeeper for work leaving a sprint, the DoR is the bouncer for work entering it. It defines when a backlog item is clear, understood, and actionable enough for the team to actually start working on it.

By drawing a hard line between these concepts, you're not just adding process—you're creating clarity and stopping half-baked work from ever derailing your team. For a deeper dive, you can explore Atlassian's insights on agile project management.

The Undeniable Benefits of a Rock-Solid DoD

Let's be honest, adopting a strict Definition of Done can feel like adding more red tape to an already tangled process. It sounds like another meeting, another checklist, another hurdle slowing things down.

But in reality, it’s the exact opposite.

A rock-solid DoD isn't bureaucracy; it's a secret weapon. It’s an investment that pays off big time in speed, quality, and—most importantly—your team's sanity.

Stop Reworking and Start Innovating

Think about your best engineer. Is she spending her days building the future of your product, or is she stuck in an endless loop fixing “minor” bugs from the last release? Every single hour spent on rework is an hour stolen from innovation. It's a creativity tax.

A clear DoD slashes that tax. By catching issues before they ever escape a sprint, you’re not just shipping better code; you’re buying back your team’s most valuable asset: their focus. This is the difference between being a feature factory constantly playing defense and becoming an innovation engine that actually builds what's next.

This is how a strong DoD directly fuels real business benefits—turning quality control into a launchpad for speed and trust.

When you bake quality in from the start, you naturally get faster, more reliable delivery and build unshakable confidence with your stakeholders. It's a simple, powerful flow.

Predictability You Can Actually Trust

How much do you sweat when you give a timeline to your boss or a customer? If you find yourself constantly hedging your bets or walking back promises, it’s probably because your definition of “done” is a moving target. Unplanned work from last sprint keeps torpedoing this sprint.

A DoD brings a level of predictability that feels like a superpower. When “done” means the exact same thing every time, your team's velocity becomes a reliable metric, not just a feel-good number for a chart.

You can finally forecast with confidence because you’ve eliminated the biggest variable: the unknown cost of fixing what you thought was already finished. This lets you set more accurate success metrics and actually hit them.

A strong DoD isn't just about shipping better code; it’s about building a reputation for reliability. It’s the foundation for trust—within the team, with leadership, and with your customers.

This isn't just a nice idea; it's a core principle. The entire Scrum framework hinges on a clear Definition of Done to keep everyone honest and the work transparent.

Fostering a Culture of Quality and Accountability

Ultimately, a shared DoD changes the entire team dynamic. It shifts conversations away from blame (“Whose fault is this bug?”) and toward shared ownership (“Did we meet our collective standard of quality?”).

It empowers everyone, from the junior dev to the senior architect, to be a guardian of quality.

When the whole team agrees on the standards upfront, accountability becomes a natural part of the culture, not something you have to enforce. This builds a profound sense of trust and psychological safety. People know what’s expected of them, and they trust that the work coming their way has already met that same high bar. That boost in morale is something you can feel—and it's what separates good teams from truly great ones.

How to Create a Definition of Done

Alright, let's get down to business. We've talked a big game about why a Definition of Done matters. Now it's time to stop talking and actually build one.

A good DoD isn't some stone tablet handed down from on high. It’s a living, breathing agreement that’s hammered out, debated, and ultimately owned by the people doing the work. If it doesn't have the fingerprints of your engineers, designers, and QA specialists all over it, it’s destined to be ignored the second a deadline gets tight.

So, let's get you something tangible you can bring to your team's next planning session.

What Goes Into a DoD Checklist?

Think of your DoD as having different levels of maturity. A scrappy startup just trying to ship its MVP will have a different standard of "done" than a fintech company managing billions in transactions. One is focused on speed, the other on not going to jail. Both are valid.

Here's a look at how a DoD checklist can evolve. It's not about being "basic" or "advanced"—it's about matching the criteria to your team's current reality.

Sample Definition of Done Checklist

Category	Basic DoD (Good Start)	Advanced DoD (Mature Team)
Code & Implementation	Code compiles, is merged to `main`, and the build isn't broken.	Peer-reviewed by at least one other engineer, adheres to style guides, and introduces no new high-severity linting errors.
Testing & Validation	Feature has been manually tested against its acceptance criteria.	Unit tests are written and passing with 80%+ coverage, integration tests are updated, and end-to-end tests cover the critical user path.
Documentation	Code is reasonably commented.	User-facing help docs are updated, internal technical docs are revised, and API documentation (if applicable) is current.
Release Readiness	Deployed to a staging environment.	Product Owner has approved the feature, performance and security scans are clean, and feature flags are in place for a controlled rollout.

This isn't just about adding more rules for the sake of it. A mature team’s DoD reflects lessons learned from past mistakes—like that one time an undocumented API change broke a key integration. Oops.

Making It Real: Ambiguity Is Your Enemy

Vague statements like "code is tested" are totally useless. They’re an invitation for debate when you can least afford it. A powerful Definition of Done uses specific, measurable criteria that leave zero room for interpretation.

Your DoD should be a checklist, not a collection of well-intentioned philosophies. Kill ambiguity at every turn.

Look at how mature agile teams operate. Their DoDs get incredibly specific. We're talking hard numbers like unit test coverage exceeding 80%, mandatory peer code reviews, and zero critical bugs before a story can even be considered for acceptance.

Let's translate those abstract categories into real-world checklist items you can actually use:

Code Quality: "All code is peer-reviewed and approved by at least one other engineer before merging."

Testing: "Unit test coverage for new code exceeds 80%."

Performance: "Database queries execute in under 100ms."

Security: "No new vulnerabilities are identified by our automated security scanner."

Documentation: "The 'Getting Started' guide is updated to reflect the new functionality."

UX/UI: "The implementation is confirmed to be pixel-perfect against the final Figma designs."

See the difference? One is a wish, the other is a contract.

Your Team, Your Rules

The checklist above isn't a one-size-fits-all prescription. The right Definition of Done for your team depends entirely on your context.

Early-Stage Startup: Your DoD might be brutally lean. Speed and learning are everything. It probably prioritizes "Deployed behind a feature flag" over "Comprehensive end-to-end test suite." You're moving fast, and that’s okay—as long as everyone agrees on what corners are being cut.

Fintech or Healthcare Company: Your DoD is going to be heavy on security and compliance. Items like "Passes security audit" and "Meets HIPAA/PCI compliance standards" are non-negotiable. Here, quality and risk mitigation trump speed every single time.

Mature SaaS Platform: Your team needs a balanced DoD. It has to cover scalability, documentation for other teams, and backward compatibility. An item like "Ensures no breaking changes to the public API" becomes absolutely critical.

The only way to get this right is through collaboration. Book a meeting with the whole crew—engineers, QA, design, and product. Start with a template like the one here and debate every single point. The document that emerges will be something everyone feels accountable for. This whole process is a lot like a healthy backlog grooming ceremony—the primary goal is creating a shared understanding.

And if you're looking for more ways to structure clear expectations, exploring other essential project management checklists can be a great way to complement your new and improved DoD.

Common Pitfalls and How to Sidestep Them

Nailing down a Definition of Done is one thing. Making it stick when things get chaotic? That’s a whole different ballgame. This is where most teams trip up.

They draft a beautiful DoD, maybe even laminate it for the wall, and then promptly forget it exists the second a deadline starts breathing down their necks.

It’s a story I’ve seen play out a dozen times. The pressure ramps up, a key stakeholder just wants the feature “shipped now,” and that carefully crafted quality pact suddenly feels more like a gentle suggestion than a hard rule.

This section is your field guide to the most common traps. Think of it as the hard-won wisdom from teams who’ve already made the mistakes, so you don't have to.

The Aspirational DoD

The first pitfall is creating a DoD that’s more of a utopian fantasy than a practical checklist. It’s packed with noble, but frankly, ridiculous goals like “100% test coverage,” “zero known bugs,” and “fully localized for all global markets.”

It looks great on paper, but in the real world, it’s completely unattainable. When the standard is perfection, the team eventually just stops trying. Your DoD becomes a source of guilt, not a tool for quality.

How to Sidestep It: Start with what’s realistic today, not what you wish were true tomorrow. Your DoD should be an honest reflection of your team’s current capabilities. You can always crank up the rigor over time during retrospectives. A good DoD is achievable; a great DoD evolves.

The DoD-in-Name-Only

This is the DoD that gets tossed out the window at the first sign of trouble. The team follows it religiously during calm sprints, but the second the timeline gets tight, it’s the first thing to go.

“We’ll skip the documentation just this once to hit the deadline.” Sound familiar? “Let’s just push the performance testing to the next sprint.”

This kind of behavior turns your DoD into a hollow artifact. It sends a clear signal to the team that quality is negotiable and only matters when it's convenient—a fast track to accumulating tech debt and absolutely crushing morale.

How to Sidestep It: Treat the DoD as non-negotiable. Period. The product manager’s role here is crucial; they have to be the guardian of the DoD, defending it against pressure to cut corners. If a story can't meet the DoD within the sprint, it’s not done. This can lead to some tough conversations, especially when you're dealing with endless scope changes. Learning how to handle scope creep is a critical skill for protecting your team and your process.

If your Definition of Done becomes optional under pressure, it was never a definition in the first place. It was just a wish list.

The Stale DoD

On the flip side of the aspirational DoD is the one that never, ever changes. The team writes it, files it away on some forgotten Confluence page, and never looks at it again.

Months roll by. The team gets better, the product gets more complex, and new tools are adopted. But the DoD? It’s frozen in time, reflecting a reality that no longer exists. A stale DoD doesn't push the team to improve; it just becomes a low bar to clear.

How to Sidestep It: Make reviewing the DoD a formal part of every single sprint retrospective. Ask these simple questions:

What parts of our DoD are slowing us down without adding real value?

What quality issues slipped through this sprint that our DoD should have caught?

Based on what we learned, how can we raise our quality bar for the next sprint?

This simple ritual transforms your DoD from a static document into a living agreement that actively drives continuous improvement. It ensures your definition of "done" gets stronger and smarter right alongside your team.

Making Your Definition of Done Stick

A Definition of Done that isn't enforced is just a wish list. It’s that laminated poster on the wall everyone ignores the second things get chaotic. To make your DoD actually stick, it has to be more than a document; it needs to become an unshakeable part of your team’s culture.

This isn’t about adding bureaucracy for the sake of it. It’s about building guardrails that make quality the path of least resistance. The goal is to make it harder to cut corners than to do things the right way.

Weave the DoD into Your Workflow

To make your DoD second nature, you have to embed it directly into the tools your team already uses every single day. Let's be real, manual checks are destined to fail. Automate accountability wherever you can.

Here are a few practical ways to do this:

Jira Workflows: Don't just have a "Done" column. Configure your Jira workflow so a ticket can't be moved to "Done" unless a "DoD Checklist" custom field has been fully checked off. Make it a hard gate, not a friendly suggestion.

Pull Request Templates: This one's a game-changer. Create a mandatory PR template in GitHub or GitLab that includes your DoD as a checklist. Engineers have to literally tick the boxes—"Unit tests written," "Docs updated," "Peer review complete"—before they can even think about requesting a merge.

Sprint Demos: Make the DoD review a formal part of your sprint demo. Before showing off the new feature, quickly run through the checklist to demonstrate that the work is truly finished, not just "code complete." This builds massive confidence with stakeholders and constantly reinforces the standard.

Defend the Definition of Done

As a product manager, one of your most critical—and frankly, most difficult—jobs is to be the guardian of the DoD. When the pressure is on to ship faster, you will be tempted to let things slide. Don't.

Every time you allow an exception, you send a message that your quality standards are negotiable. This is a slippery slope that leads right back to where you started: rework, tech debt, and a demoralized team.

When stakeholders push back, don’t just say "no." Use it as an opportunity to educate them on the value of your process. Frame it in terms they understand: "By sticking to our DoD, we prevent the costly bugs and late-night rework that slowed down our last major release. This process actually makes us faster in the long run."

Use metrics to back it up. Show how a stricter DoD correlates with a decrease in bug reports or a reduction in time spent on hotfixes. Data transforms your defense from an opinion into a sound business argument. This is how you turn a simple checklist into a core part of your team's identity.

DoD FAQs (The Stuff Everyone Asks)

Even with a solid plan, a few questions always pop up. Let's tackle the usual suspects to clear up any confusion before you put your Definition of Done into action.

Who’s on the Hook for Creating the Definition of Done?

The whole team. Full stop.

Sure, a Product Manager or Scrum Master might kick things off, but the DoD has to be a group project. You need buy-in from everyone who touches the work—developers, QA, designers, the whole crew. If it’s handed down from on high, it’s doomed from the start. Ownership has to be a shared responsibility if you want accountability to actually mean something.

Can We Change the Definition of Done Later?

You'd better. Your DoD isn’t some sacred text carved into a stone tablet; it’s a living document that has to grow with your team.

As your team gets better, brings in new tech, or learns a tough lesson from a disastrous release, your standards have to rise. The name of the game is continuous improvement, and your DoD is one of the best tools you have to make that happen.

What Happens If a Story Doesn’t Meet the DoD?

Simple: it’s not done. Period.

That means it doesn't count toward the sprint's velocity, and it sure as hell doesn't get shipped to customers. The work gets punted back to the product backlog to be re-estimated and re-prioritized for a future sprint. This might feel a little harsh at first, but it's the only way to guard your quality and keep your development process predictable. Anything less is just lying to yourself.

Ready to build a culture of quality without all the chaos? Momentum brings your entire agile workflow—from planning to retrospectives—into one sane, unified platform. Ditch the tool-juggling and focus on shipping software that’s actually done. See how it works.